Tommy Thompson gets a big Thank YOU! (from the formula industry)

Dear Mama,
Way way back in 2003 I did these comics about the silencing of an ad campaign meant to promote breastfeeding: Handbasket! and MOCK MOCK!
and this just in (thanks Carolyn Y, Julia M, Christy N, Janna H, Janaki D, Mia O, and Ingrid VdP, if I forgot anyone, sorry!):

HHS Toned Down Breast-Feeding Ads By Marc Kaufman and Christopher Lee

In an attempt to raise the nation’s historically low rate of breast-feeding, federal health officials commissioned an attention-grabbing advertising campaign a few years ago to convince mothers that their babies faced real health risks if they did not breast-feed. It featured striking photos of insulin syringes and asthma inhalers topped with rubber nipples.

Plans to run these blunt ads infuriated the politically powerful infant formula industry, which hired a former chairman of the Republican National Committee and a former top regulatory official to lobby the Health and Human Services Department. Not long afterward, department political appointees toned down the campaign.

The ads ran instead with more friendly images of dandelions and cherry-topped ice cream scoops, to dramatize how breast-feeding could help avert respiratory problems and obesity. In a February 2004 letter, the lobbyists told then-HHS Secretary Tommy G. Thompson they were “grateful” for his staff’s intervention to stop health officials from “scaring expectant mothers into breast-feeding,” and asked for help in scaling back more of the ads.

The formula industry’s intervention - which did not block the ads but helped change their content - is being scrutinized by Congress in the wake of last month’s testimony by former surgeon general Richard H. Carmona that the Bush administration repeatedly allowed political considerations to interfere with his efforts to promote public health.

Rep. Henry A. Waxman’s Committee on Oversight and Government Reform is investigating allegations from former officials that Carmona was blocked from participating in the breast-feeding advocacy effort and that those designing the ad campaign were overruled by superiors at the formula industry’s insistence.

“This is a credible allegation of political interference that might have had serious public health consequences,” said Waxman, a California Democrat.

wow. You kind of suspected didn’t you? but seeing the proof of it makes me really think we might be IN that handbasket. wow.

Love,
Heather

3 Comments »

  1. Mama Bear said,

    September 4, 2007 @ 3:02 pm

    Hathor,

    Your newest comic, “Tommy Makes Excuses!” literally made me laugh out loud. Soooooo on-point. I have my own take on the matter, but I can’t help but agree with the way you said it.

    My take: http://www.breastfeedingsymbol.org/2007/09/01/breastfeeding-ad-campaign-hoopla/, which I continue to re-examine, especially after reading the last few cartoons you posted.

  2. TastesLikeCrazy said,

    September 5, 2007 @ 6:27 am

    Love the cartoon. It “says” a lot of the things that I was thinking.

    I wrote about this on the 31st with the ad pictures, and it’s nice to see the issue being discussed.

    http://tastelikecrazy.com/2007/08/31/can-i-get-an-inhaler-with-that-dandelion/

  3. amyphilo said,

    September 5, 2007 @ 7:20 am

    When I saw this story a few days ago I put it up on my website on the front page. The next day I decided to read the whole thing completely, so I followed the link, but MSNBC had taken the story down. I did a search for the article on their website and couldn’t find anything relating to it. So I did a google search for it and the first place I found the full text was on Michael Moore’s sicko site. For posterity I have the original MSNBC link still up on my front page, along with the full-text version (it’s a bit longer than this version on your blog but well worth a read). www.babywhys.org

    There’s also a link on the front page of babywhys to a yahoo group which is organizing a nationwide nurse-in at Applebee’s.
    Amy

RSS feed for comments on this post · TrackBack URI

Leave a Comment




  • Meta